Chamonix-Mont-Blanc english summary
The event concerns the Panoramic Mont-Blanc cable car located in the Chamonix commune on the Mont-Blanc massif.
At 15:20, on Thursday, 8 September 2016, following an unexpected stoppage of the device, oscillations of the line occurred and led to a tangling of the traction cable with the carrying cable on three parts of the line.
A cable “untangling” procedure was therefore initiated. The sudden breaking of part of the motor interrupted and prevented this procedure from being completed.
At 17:20 the cable car was still stopped with 110 passengers on the line. All options for restarting it seemed exhausted. A helicopter evacuation was therefore decided upon.
54 people were rescued by 20:50, which was nightfall time. 24 other people were rescued by 22:30, but via vertical rescue and walking along the glacier. 32 people remained in the cabins all night.
During the night, the motor was repaired. A new attempt to untangle the cables was carried out at 07:15, with success. It however caused a new incident : the derailing of an empty cabin from the carrying cable. The repatriation of the last passengers was carried out at a low speed and was completed by 08:50. They were stuck on the line since 17:30.
The initiatory fact of the prolonged immobilisation of the cable car was the trigger of a safety feature that theoretically should have made the installation safer. This safety feature was activated due to a modification in the setting of the installation carried out the day before.
The latent defaults and a weak resistance of the installation and its operation led to a progressive degradation of the situation, which the operator didn’t know how to manage without using public rescue services.
The causes of the prolonged immobilisation and its repercussions were :
- the sensitivity of the device to oscillations of the traction cable which led it to cross the carrying cable in several places and thus led to immobilisation ;
- the breaking, during an attempt to uncross the cables, of a badly crimped hose on a motor that had just been replaced and whose ability to uncross the cables had not been verified ;
- the omission of devices reducing certain risks of immobilisation, due to an incomplete safety study ;
- the overestimation, before the event, of passengers’ ability to withstand hostile environments, for a long duration, and the underestimation of the assistance they would need ;
- the lack of operational rigor to ensure a high level of safety of the installation.
BEA-TT issued five recommendations and an invitation in the following areas :
- knowledge of dynamic effects on the Panoramic Mont-Blanc ;
- the safety of cabins with regard to derailing ;
- operational rigor for the maintenance of a high level of safety ;
- the consistence of feasibility testing concerning, more generally, installations sensitive to dynamic effects ;
- the quality of cable car safety studies for integrated evacuations ;
- the vigilance of cable cars safety control services.
Sur le même sujet
Pra Loup english summary
Technical inquiry report on the fall of a cabin on the Costebelle gondola on March 25, 2018 in Pra Loup (04)
5 septembre 2023
Gourette Les Bosses english summary
Technical inquiry report on the fall of a car of the Bosses cable-car on 2 February 2013 at the Gourette ski area in Eaux-Bonnes (64)
26 février 2020
Gourette Fontaines-de-Cotch english summary
Technical inquiry report on the fall of a skier from the ‘Fontaines-de-Cotch’ chairlift on 22 December 2012 at the Gourette ski area in (…)
26 février 2020
La Plagne english summary
Technical inquiry report on the Telemétro derailment which occurred on 12 January 2017 in La Plagne (73)
26 février 2020